Skip to content 
Pros and Cons of Installing New Shingles Over Old Roofing
A roof overlay—adding a second layer of shingles over existing shingles—can be an affordable option, but it’s not without risks. Evaluating the current roof’s condition, potential roof leaks, roofing materials, and resale value with a roofing professional is key to making a wise decision.
Installing new shingles over an existing roof is a practical yet debated solution in residential roofing. The appeal lies in its cost savings and reduced labor, but it’s not a one-size-fits-all approach. Homeowners must carefully examine the condition of their current roof, understand local building code requirements, and consider how long they plan to remain in the home.
A roof overlay may sometimes be suitable, but it isn’t always the best long-term solution. Schedule a professional inspection with MLM Home Improvement to ensure the right choice is made. Our team can guide you through the process and recommend the most reliable and cost-effective options available for your home.
What Does It Mean to Install New Shingles Over Old Roofing?
Installing a second layer of shingles—often referred to as a roof overlay—involves placing new shingles directly over the existing ones without removing the original layer. This method is frequently chosen as a more affordable and less labor-intensive alternative to a complete roof replacement.
However, although a roof overlay might seem convenient, it has limitations. It hinders a thorough inspection of the roof deck and may hide underlying damage, such as moisture intrusion or deteriorated sheathing. These concealed issues can undermine the long-term integrity of the roofing system if not addressed.
Pros of Installing New Shingles Over Old Roofing
One of the most appealing benefits of installing new shingles over old ones is the potential for significant cost savings. By skipping the tear-off process, homeowners can reduce labor and disposal expenses, making it a budget-friendly option for many.
The overall timeline for the roofing project has also been shortened. Since the crew can begin installing the new layer of shingles immediately, homeowners experience less disruption, and the job can often be completed more quickly than a full roof replacement.
Another advantage is the reduced mess. Without removing old shingles, there’s far less debris to manage, resulting in a cleaner job site and potentially lower cleanup and disposal fees. In some cases, roofing contractors may even offer discounted rates for this streamlined approach.
Cons of Installing New Shingles Over Old Roofing
One of the most significant drawbacks of layering new shingles over an existing roof is the risk of concealed damage. Old shingles may hide issues such as rotting wood or damaged sheathing, which could compromise the roof’s overall structural integrity if not adequately addressed.
The added weight of a second layer of shingles can strain the roof structure, particularly in older homes or areas where heavy snow accumulation is typical. In some cases, this additional load can exceed the limits set by local building codes, leading to potential safety concerns and non-compliance issues.
Another consideration is the manufacturer’s warranty. Many shingle manufacturers require a clean, flat surface for installation, and placing new shingles over an uneven or aged surface can void the warranty. This means homeowners may not be protected if issues arise, making proper installation and surface prep critical.
Roofing Code and Warranty Considerations
Most local building codes limit the number of roof layers that can be installed. In many regions, more than two layers are prohibited, making it crucial to check the regulations before starting the project.
Even if allowed, adding only one layer on top of an existing one can affect the manufacturer’s warranty. Some shingle manufacturers clearly state that their warranty is void if their product is applied over another layer.
Understanding the number of roof layers present and what is permitted under local and state regulations will save time, money, and potential legal issues down the line.
When a Tear-Off is the Better Option
Opting for a complete tear-off may require more labor upfront, but it offers the most thorough and long-lasting solution for your roof. By removing the old shingles, your roofing contractor gains full visibility of the roof deck, allowing them to identify and address hidden issues like moisture damage, rotting wood, or compromised sheathing.
This clean-slate approach enhances the integrity and performance of the new asphalt shingle roof, helping to prevent roof leaks and structural concerns down the line. It also ensures proper installation on a flat, stable surface—essential for longevity and warranty compliance.
A full roof replacement not only protects your home better but also increases energy efficiency and can significantly enhance its resale value. For homeowners looking for a dependable, future-proof solution, a tear-off offers peace of mind and a long-term investment in their property’s value.
Factors to Consider Before Deciding
Before committing to a roof overlay or a tear-off, several important factors must be evaluated. These will help determine whether your roof is a good candidate for a second layer of shingles:
- Condition of Current Shingles: If the existing shingles are in good shape, lying flat, and there’s only one layer, a new layer may be an option.
- Signs of Damage: Curling, cracking, or moisture-related issues are red flags. These problems indicate the need for a full tear-off and inspection.
- Type of Roofing Materials: Not all roofing materials are compatible for layering. Compatibility between the existing layer and the new shingles is essential for proper adhesion and performance.
- Roof Structure Integrity: The structural condition of the roof deck must be evaluated to ensure it can support the additional weight of a second layer.
- Local Building Codes: Local building codes may restrict the number of layers of shingles that can be installed. It’s important to confirm compliance before proceeding.
To avoid costly mistakes and ensure the success of your roofing project, schedule an inspection with a licensed roofing professional from MLM Home Improvement. Our team will evaluate your roof’s condition and help you make the most reliable and cost-effective decision.
Final Verdict: Should You Install New Shingles Over Old?
Choosing between a roof overlay and a complete replacement depends on your roof’s current condition, long-term goals, and budget. If your existing shingles are in good shape and there’s only one layer, a roof overlay might be a reasonable short-term solution.
However, a complete tear-off often delivers better long-term value. It allows for thorough inspection, ensures proper installation, extends the roof’s lifespan, and can boost your home’s resale value. Knowing that your new roofing system starts from a clean foundation also gives you peace of mind.
To make the best decision for your home, consult an MLM Home Improvement roofing expert. We’ll evaluate your roof, explain your options clearly, and help you move forward with a plan that’s safe, cost-effective, and built to last.
Trust MLM Home Improvement
Deciding between a new layer of shingles and a complete roof replacement involves several key factors: your budget, local building codes, the condition of your existing shingles, and the integrity of your roof deck.
Partnering with a trusted roofing company like MLM Home Improvement ensures your project is handled with expert care from start to finish. Our experienced team can guide you through your options, whether you’re considering durable architectural shingles or a classic asphalt shingle system.
Don’t leave your roof’s future to chance. Contact MLM Home Improvement today for a professional assessment and customized recommendation tailored to your home’s needs and long-term goals. Let us help you weigh the pros and cons of installing new shingles over old roofing so you can confidently move forward.
